So now that we are solidly into the Glee season, I feel I can comment on what I’ve seen so far. I have often found that you have to wait a few episodes to really form any kind of opinion because it takes that long for characters to emerge and potential hilarity to ensue. It’s really rare that a series pilot is really *that* awesome.
That said, Glee had a good pilot. I had to love the way they break into song because that can be incredibly cheesetastic or make you smile and/or hum along. And somehow they managed to be both. You laugh because you have to – there is no choice. Followed quickly by a groan, followed quickly by another laugh.
Also, I cannot say enough about Jane Lynch. I really feel that she deserves every good word she gets, def one of the most underrated actresses ever. Her comic timing is to die for and every facial expression floors me.
So, now to the poop.
I really hate cliches and the first few episodes quickly tumbled down the garden path toward cliche hell. I held my breath for it, figuratively of course, and expected them to do some dumb things at every turn. Happily they surprised me roughly 50% of the time which is more than I can say for, oh every other sitcom out there. (mad kudos to arrested development though – esp for knowing when to call it quits. part of the problem really)
The characters are ok though some of the storylines are so played out already just 8 episodes in. That scene in Holy Grail with the soldiers all yelling “GET ON WITH IT” comes to mind 2 or 3 times throughout an episode. We get the angst. We get the drama. But I guess high school IS angsty drama, so what else can they write about?
I also am ever so slightly turned off by the canned music and the lame attempts to lip synch. Obviously they cant sing and do some of those dance steps at the same time. Only N’Sync can do that. And that’s ok. We’re ok with that and would rather just hear good solid vocals. WHich is abounding. Otoh, it might be nice in future episodes to have them actually sing, not produced, just for fun.
OK, the other big problem I have with the show is that whole married teacher thing. My friend Kyle said it best when he commented how he didn’t like the way they set you up to root for the guy to cheat on his wife. The show made his wife a lunatic and just not a very nice person, but then again Emma, the guidance counselor is a total freak and full of crap too, so I feel fairly neutral about the whole thing. Again, they are taking weeks to develop the story and I feel each episode has done the two steps forward one step back thing. This is why I wait for the whole season to come out on DVD. Oh well, I’m hooked now and I hope the rest of the season does not totally change the name from Glee to Blow.
